Law

Why Elder Help Network Is Fighting for a 90-Year-Old Stroke Survivor: The Sam Polyak Polykup & David Gutwill Ultimate Car Care Case Explained

When a 90-year-old stroke survivor becomes the alleged victim of a $200,000 vehicle parts disappearance, it raises urgent questions about protections for America’s elderly.

In response, Elder Help Network has taken the unusual step of filing a Motion to Appear as Amicus Curiae in New Jersey Superior Court. The filing supports Robert Kerekes in his lawsuit against Sam Polyak of Polykup and involves David Gutwill of Ultimate Car Care.

Court documents describe how a planned premium EV conversion of Kerekes’ prized 2003 Acura NSX allegedly turned into a case of elder abuse. High-value Tesla batteries were reportedly replaced with hazardous recalled Chevrolet Bolt batteries. After Judge Frank DeAngelis issued a Writ of Replevin, the car was returned missing its engine, transmission, and other expensive components.

Elder Help Network is calling on the court to enforce its own order, issue subpoenas, and consider criminal charges for theft and elder financial exploitation.

This filing demonstrates the important role advocacy organizations play in elder abuse cases. By providing specialized knowledge to the court, groups like Elder Help Network help ensure that laws designed to protect seniors — such as New Jersey’s Adult Protective Services Act — are properly applied.

What Families Should Learn From This Case

  • Always put major contracts in writing
  • Verify parts and work quality
  • Monitor transactions involving elderly relatives closely
  • Report suspected elder abuse immediately

The court has not yet ruled on the amicus motion. The full details are available in the official press release: https://elderhelpnetwork.com/elder-help-network-files-amicus-brief-in-new-jersey-elder-abuse-case-involving-90-year-old-stroke-survivor/